Designing
Behavior.

Increasing transplant referrals and broadening perceived kidney options through behavioral design.

  • Service design
  • Research
  • UX
Clinician consulting a phone
Challenge
Increase referrals from dialysis centers to transplant centers and widen the kidneys patients and clinicians were willing to accept. The work meant designing around the biases behind those decisions.
My Role
Service Designer. Owned the Change Package of 68 best-practice initiatives, led patient and clinician user interviews, built the metrics and data visualizations behind the digital tools, and guided implementation in dialysis centers.
Team Structure
Service Design Lead, Service Designer (me), Visual Designer, Project Manager. A healthcare client as the sponsor.
Impact
Two shipped products: a patient booklet now in dialysis center waiting rooms and a Change Package of 68 best-practice initiatives for dialysis centers nationwide.

Overview

Transplants offer longer lives than dialysis, but getting there depends on patients weighing hope and surgeons weighing risk. Bias and cognitive load shape which kidneys are accepted and which are discarded.

At Fjord, we created a patient booklet and a Change Package to help dialysis centers encourage transplant, including High-KDPI kidneys often passed over. I reframed the work around bias, designing for better decisions by patients, clinicians, and the system around them.

The problem

Transplants give patients longer lives and better outcomes than years of dialysis, and the system has the kidneys to do it: nearly 20,000 recovered from deceased donors every year. But almost 20% of those kidneys are discarded instead of transplanted, and 11 people a day die waiting for the ones that are.

Reasons for kidney discard nationally, 2014–2018, with 2018 recovery and transplant totals

Mapping the full journey

Kidney transplant journey, full process

The first drop-off is medically binary: a kidney either matches basic criteria or it doesn’t. The design opportunity is upstream of the drop-off: accelerating how the clinical information gets captured and how fast it reaches the decision-makers downstream.

Kidney transplant journey opportunity 1

The waitlist ping-pong

A kidney moves down the waitlist, offered to one transplant center after another. Communication and logistics consume critical time, increasing the chance that a viable kidney is ultimately discarded.

Kidney transplant journey opportunity 2

Drop-off at the patient offer

Patients wanted more say in which kidneys worked for them, but were often unprepared for the cognitive load and complexity of the offer. Many defaulted to rejection, optimistic that a better kidney would arrive soon.

Kidney transplant journey opportunity 3

Changing the bias behavior upstream increased the number of viable kidneys available for patients to accept.

LABELING BIAS

The association of a set of characteristics with a certain label. “If we're number 3500 on the match run, they've probably dropped it on the floor and stepped on it.”

Upstream design

It's Never Too Late patient story and practical transplant advice booklet

Ethnographic interviews with patients and families became five user stories built to meet patients where their biases actually lived. Journeys in their own words, quotes they’d recognize, take-away advice, and a “life after transplant” section built to make the possibility feel real rather than abstract. Transplant terminology got rewritten in the way patients actually talk. High-KDPI kidneys got reframed as the ones that could get someone off dialysis sooner. The booklet lives where patients spend four hours every other day: the waiting room distributed itself.

Risk aversion plays a major role in shaping how organ offer decision- makers (typically transplant surgeons) view kidney offers. Surgeons don't want to transplant a kidney they believe could put their patient or transplant program at risk: these risks seem more temporally powerful than the patient's long-term gains. Cognitive burden among surgeons is also evident; while the organ allocation technology provides clinical information on the organ donor, the surgeon must use their best clinical judgment to compare that data to the clinical characteristics of their patient. We designed a tool to alleviate these biases and cognitive load through data visualization and transparency.

Decision point design

Annotated clinical decision support screen comparing donor and patient characteristicsFuture allocation technology across the kidney transplant ecosystem

We built solutions across the ecosystem so that more kidneys were accepted across the process

Outcomes

The work also increased understanding of KDPI, established transplant as a natural next step, and increased education efforts for advocacy.

65%

Increased speed of decisions

48%

Increased kidney acceptance rate

25%

Increased acceptance of high risk kidneys